Skip to main content
Email

The latest news in Healthcare IT – straight to your inbox.

Home
  • Main Menu
  • Subscribe
  • Topics
    • Video
    • Analytics
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • Cloud Computing
    • EHR
    • Government & Policy
    • Interoperability
    • Patient Engagement
    • Population Health
    • Precision Medicine
    • Privacy & Security
    • Telehealth
    • Women In Health IT

Regions

  • ANZ
  • ASIA
  • EMEA
  • Global Edition
Global Edition
Medical Devices

Lawmakers ask CDRH to revisit its CDS guidance

In a letter to the FDA, members of Congress cite confusion over providers' deployment of clinical decision support software that is exempt from medical device regulations and call for clarity from its Center for Devices and Radiological Health.
By Andrea Fox
November 15, 2024
10:20 AM

Photo: Sarah Silbiger/Getty Images

In a letter to Dr. Michelle Tarver, newly appointed director of the Center for Devices and Radiological Health, a division of the Food and Drug Administration, seven members of Congress have asked the agency to clarify guidance that followed 21st Century Cures Act exemptions for clinical decision support from regulation as medical devices.

"FDA’s guidance does not reflect its typical risk-based approach or consider the significant clinical oversight under which these tools are configured," they said Tuesday.

WHY IT MATTERS

Congress exempted CDS from regulation as medical devices, provided they meet certain criteria, but lawmakers, led by Dan Crenshaw, R-Texas, and Ann McLane Kuster, D-N.H., provide clear advice.

"The FDA seems to list internally inconsistent examples of where the exception would apply," they said in a letter shared with Healthcare IT News.

"For instance, the FDA’s guidance indicates that CDS tools cannot qualify for the exemption unless they provide multiple recommendations."

CDS tools often provide a single recommendation when users determine there is only one appropriate option based on clinical practice guidelines.

"This guidance would seem to make much of CDS used throughout the healthcare system ineligible for the exemption," the lawmakers said, adding that time-critical situations fail the requirement for clinician reviews of CDS recommendations.

THE LARGER TREND

The lawmakers noted that in May the House Committee on Energy and Commerce asked the previous CDRH director, Dr. Jeff Shuren, about specific CDS tools that recommend single courses of action, and said his responses created "additional uncertainty for medical technology developers and providers."

Committee members asked Shuren and other FDA division directors what challenges they were facing and why they were not meeting critical performance processes and hiring goals, at times grilling the agency leaders over critical medical device missteps. 

Shuren said that most medical devices aren't getting to patients due to numerous obstacles from concept to commercialization. 

"It is appropriately called the valley of death," he said.

Crenshaw and Angie Craig, D-Minn., wrote to Tarver in September while she served as acting CDRH director after Shuren's departure in July with questions regarding the agency's intentions expressed in the Laboratory Developed Tests Final Rule. That rule would phase out its LDT enforcement discretion policy over a four-year period. 

ON THE RECORD 

"Many healthcare organizations deploy hundreds of CDS tools, and providers need clarity to determine whether their tools constitute a medical device and whether they must go through the medical device clearance process accordingly," the lawmakers said in their letter to Tarver.

"We urge the FDA to revisit its guidance and provide clear advice aligned with the 21st Century Cures Act’s language."

Andrea Fox is senior editor of Healthcare IT News.
Email: afox@himss.org

Healthcare IT News is a HIMSS Media publication.

Topics: 
Compliance & Legal, Decision Support, Government & Policy, Medical Devices, Quality and Safety

More regional news

Patient does a virtual care consult

Castlight Health intros virtual urgent care for members

By
Mike Miliard
April 18, 2025
HIMSSCast logo

HIMSSCast: Should every healthcare organization have an AI strategy?

By
Mike Miliard
April 18, 2025
Nurse checks tablet to communicate on shift

Zoom launches agentic AI-powered mobile comms for frontline staff

By
Andrea Fox
April 18, 2025
Want to get more stories like this one? Get daily news updates from Healthcare IT News.
Your subscription has been saved.
Something went wrong. Please try again.

Top Story

Nurse checks tablet to communicate on shift
Zoom launches agentic AI-powered mobile comms for frontline staff

Most Read

How UCHealth is reducing fall injuries with AI-enhanced risk modeling
Australia infuses $85M in digital mental health and more briefs
Korea University Medical Center pursues brain, heart AI development and more briefs
HIMSSCast: Fundamentals of data governance - lessons from UNC Health, part 1
Texting the CEO proves wildly popular at Banner Health
Chinese health players begin integrating DeepSeek

Research

White Papers

More Whitepapers

Telehealth
Create secure, connected omnichannel communications
Telehealth
Let us guide you to HIPAA compliance
Cloud Computing
How a cloud communications platform puts connection at the center of care

Webinars

More Webinars

Analytics
Standby Eligibility and Claims Solutions: Diversify Your Risk & Ensure Business Continuity
Interoperability
Nursing Leadership, Operational Innovation, and Emerging Technologies with AONL
Artificial Intelligence
Loving the AI Revolution: How Automation is Humanizing Healthcare and Improving Provider Well-Being

Video

Ilir Kullolli, Stanford Medicine Children's Health_Las Vegas skyline Photo by halbergman/E+/Getty Images
HIMSS-ACCE working together to advance digital health
Vik Bajaj, Foresite Labs_Medical research Photo by Edward Jenner/pexels.com
Healthcare research is being affected by federal budget cuts
Priyanka Jain, Evvy_Hand holding sample vial Photo courtesy of Evvy
How one women's health startup tests fertility outcomes
Keisuke Nakagawa, UC San Diego Health_Las Vegas skyline Photo by halbergman/E+/Getty Images
Can technology help bring the human touch back to medicine?

More Stories

Lee Kim, HIMSS_Las Vegas skyline Photo by halbergman/E+/Getty Images
Past year's data breaches often stemmed from remediable cybersecurity gaps
Cathy Menkiena, Health Catalyst_Las Vegas skyline Photo by halbergman/E+/Getty Images
Innovative – and useful – tech is key to empowering care teams
Sameer Sethi of Hackensack Meridian Health on AI
Hackensack Meridian Chief AI Officer on the intersection of business and technology
Doctor checking and tracking information on a computer
HHS updates regulatory guides for the safe use of EHRs
Sameer Sethi, Hackensack Meridian Health_Computer neural network concept Photo by dan/Moment/Getty Images
Chief AI Officer on becoming one and working with the C-suite
Businessperson signing piece of paper
White House releases guidance on federal AI use and procurement
Dr. Ateev Mehrotra of Brown University School of Public Health on telehealth policy
Brown University policy expert talks about the future of telehealth flexibilities
Micky Tripathi, former HHS acting chief AI officer
Former National Coordinator headed to Mayo Clinic, reports say
Home

More News

  • MobiHealthNews
  • Healthcare Finance News
  • Healthcare Payers News

Newsletter Signup

HIMSS25 European Health Conference & Exhibition
HIMSS25 European Health Conference & Exhibition
Get ready for knowledge-sharing, all the latest innovations, and in-depth demos with Europe's most influential healthcare community.
10 - 12 June, 2025 | Paris
Learn More
AI in Healthcare Forum
AI in Healthcare Forum
The HIMSS AI in Healthcare Forum cuts through the hype to showcase real-world examples illustrating the transformative potential, and realistic challenges of AI application across the care continuum.
10 - 11 July 2025 | New York
Learn More

Footer Menu

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Reprints
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy

© 2025 Healthcare IT News is a publication of HIMSS Media

X

Topics

  • Video
  • Analytics
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Cloud Computing
  • EHR
  • Government & Policy
  • Interoperability
  • Patient Engagement
  • Population Health
  • Precision Medicine
  • Privacy & Security
  • Telehealth
  • Women In Health IT

Career

  • Events
  • Jobs
  • Research Papers
  • Webinars

More

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Special Projects
  • Video

Regions

  • ANZ
  • ASIA
  • EMEA
  • Global Edition

The Daily Brief Newsletter

Get daily news updates from Healthcare IT News.

Search form

Top Stories

Nurse checks tablet to communicate on shift
Zoom launches agentic AI-powered mobile comms for frontline staff
HIMSSCast logo
HIMSSCast: Should every healthcare organization have an AI strategy?
Vik Bajaj, Foresite Labs_Medical research Photo by Edward Jenner/pexels.com
Healthcare research is being affected by federal budget cuts