Welcome to HIMSS

This site uses technologies such as cookies to provide a better user experience by personalising content and ads, analysing web traffic and trends, and improving site operations. We may share information about your use of the site with third parties in accordance with our Privacy Policy. By continuing to use this site you agree that we can save cookies on your device, unless you have disabled them. You can change your cookie settings at any time by visiting our Cookie Policy, but parts of our site may not function correctly without them.

Skip to main content
Email

The latest news in Healthcare IT – straight to your inbox.

Home
  • Main Menu
  • Subscribe
  • Topics
    • Video
    • Analytics
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • Cloud Computing
    • EHR
    • Government & Policy
    • Interoperability
    • Patient Engagement
    • Population Health
    • Precision Medicine
    • Privacy & Security
    • Telehealth
    • Women In Health IT

Regions

  • ANZ
  • ASIA
  • EMEA
  • Global Edition
Global Edition
Quality and Safety

At UMich, AI-based fraud, waste and abuse system aims to cut costs and protect patients

Dr. Mohammed Saeed from the University of Michigan Medical School discusses how the artificial intelligence tools can help improve provider practice patterns, potentially shielding patients from the harms of inappropriate or unnecessary care.
By Bill Siwicki
August 01, 2023
10:56 AM

Dr. Mohammed Saeed, cardiologist and researcher at the University of Michigan Medical School

Photo: Dr. Mohammed Saeed

Healthcare costs have spiraled out of control in the United States. But studies have shown how as much as one-third of healthcare expenditures can be attributed to wasteful or fraudulent healthcare services.

THE PROBLEM

There's also evidence that underserved communities are at higher risk for receiving wasteful care – and exposure to unnecessary procedures that may potentially cause harm while increasing their financial burden from out-of-pocket payments.

"The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, private payers and third party administrators have used various utilization management and payment integrity systems to analyze healthcare transactions in order to identify fraud, waste and abuse," said Dr. Mohammed Saeed, cardiologist and researcher at the University of Michigan Medical School in Ann Arbor.

"However, conventional software platforms have thus far been unable to curtail the costs associated with fraud, waste and abuse," he continued. "Among the problems, most conventional solutions are designed to analyze transactions for an average patient – who may not exist."

Conventional payment integrity systems are imprecise and impersonal, and lack a deep and clinically nuanced understanding of the patient, the provider and the healthcare setting of the services being rendered, he added.

"The same procedure may be high-value and beneficial for one patient while being wasteful for a different patient," he explained. "For example, a pacemaker implant for one patient may be highly beneficial with respect to improvement in quality of life, while providing little or no clinical benefit to another patient with different complex medical characteristics.

"Moreover, there are associated potential complications from a pacemaker implant and risk of post-procedure complications that patients face – thus, it is imperative that providers are dissuaded from rendering inappropriate procedures through use of 'smarter' systems," he continued.

Healthcare transactional data also is inherently "noisy" and may include nonspecific diagnoses and incorrect procedure codes – or missing data altogether, he added.

"The inconsistent fidelity of claims data and lack of personalization in conventional payment integrity platforms thus lead to errors in classifying fraud, waste and abuse services," he stated. "Payment integrity systems that are rigid can incorrectly classify transactions as fraud, waste and abuse, which can lead to increased provider abrasion while introducing delays and inefficiencies in healthcare delivery.

"However, such systems also are vulnerable to evolving provider schemes designed to avoid detection and thus fail to prevent payments from going out for inappropriate care services," he said.

PROPOSAL

IT vendor Health at Scale has created a special class of artificial intelligence-based algorithms designed to uncover high-confidence, low-value care that is missed by existing utilization management and payment integrity systems. Dr. Saeed is chief medical officer at Health at Scale.

"Such algorithms have a deeper and more clinically nuanced characterization of each transaction by factoring in historical information about each patient while drilling down to each provider's practice patterns; and they incorporate knowledge graphs with the most up-to-date evidence and guidelines regarding appropriateness of care," Saeed explained.

"The system also is optimized to avoid provider abrasion by focusing on a small fraction of providers that are responsible for the most egregious patterns of inappropriate care," he continued.

Such algorithms are intended to be deployed in prior authorization and claims adjudication and payment workflows.

"These algorithms scan administrative claims and transactions across prior authorization, prepay and postpay workflows with the goal of stopping fraud, waste and abuse before care is delivered or payments are made," Saeed noted. "The system also integrates with existing systems via API or standalone user interface."

RESULTS

The University of Michigan Medical School does not have any hard results yet. Health at Scale, however, has measured a variety of its healthcare provider organization clients.

When a claim is passed through the vendor's system, the response time is typically less than 200 milliseconds, Health at Scale reported. Across various deployments, the vendor is seeing between 3% and 7% of total spend that is missed by existing payment integrity tools that is then surfaced by systems for avoidance and recovery.

About 95% of the flagged activity that has been passed on to worker teams has been classified as fraud, waste or abuse. Health at Scale claims high accuracy because it applies multiple factors when reaching decisions about a claim, including historical information about each patient and provider, determination of whether care that is rendered is statistically similar to what other providers do, and factors in clinical nuance and evidence-based knowledge graphs.

ADVICE FOR OTHERS

"As a cardiologist, many patients visit my clinic seeking a second opinion regarding the potential benefit of an elective procedure recommended by an outside provider," Saeed said. "Almost half the time, I reach the conclusion that the recommended procedure would likely not be beneficial or is the wrong type of procedure altogether.

"Various studies across other specialties have also found that patients often receive medically inappropriate elective procedures," he noted. "Not only do these inappropriate procedures contribute to skyrocketing healthcare costs, but patients are exposed to risks of harm due to procedural complications or set patients up for cascades of inappropriate follow-up care."

Healthcare organizations should pick a fraud, waste and abuse system that is simple to deploy at scale, and must consider their own personnel resources to understand whether other add-on services are needed to maximize impact, he advised.

"AI-based tools that can be seamlessly deployed and integrated with existing workflows can help organizations realize almost immediate ROI," he said. "And I would recommend organizations think boldly about the prevention of inappropriate care services. Organizations should avoid unnecessary complex analyses, redundant pilot studies and tiny incremental changes that in effect do not change the status quo.

"In the long-term, I strongly believe that innovative and differentiated fraud, waste and abuse systems driven by AI will also impact provider practice patterns so that low-value care is less often rendered, and potentially shield patients from the harms of inappropriate or unnecessary care services," he concluded.

Follow Bill's HIT coverage on LinkedIn: Bill Siwicki
Email him: bsiwicki@himss.org
Healthcare IT News is a HIMSS Media publication.

Topics: 
Artificial Intelligence, Quality and Safety

More regional news

Patient does a virtual care consult

Castlight Health intros virtual urgent care for members

By
Mike Miliard
April 18, 2025
HIMSSCast logo

HIMSSCast: Should every healthcare organization have an AI strategy?

By
Mike Miliard
April 18, 2025
Nurse checks tablet to communicate on shift

Zoom launches agentic AI-powered mobile comms for frontline staff

By
Andrea Fox
April 18, 2025
Want to get more stories like this one? Get daily news updates from Healthcare IT News.
Your subscription has been saved.
Something went wrong. Please try again.

Top Story

Nurse checks tablet to communicate on shift
Zoom launches agentic AI-powered mobile comms for frontline staff

Most Read

How UCHealth is reducing fall injuries with AI-enhanced risk modeling
2025: AI enhances personalized care; caregiver experience in the spotlight
Frontera launches with $32M in seed funding
Korea University Medical Center pursues brain, heart AI development and more briefs
Roundup: AI and cloud tackle cyber risk and improve workflows
HIMSSCast: Fundamentals of data governance - lessons from UNC Health, part 1

Research

White Papers

More Whitepapers

Telehealth
Create secure, connected omnichannel communications
Telehealth
Let us guide you to HIPAA compliance
Cloud Computing
How a cloud communications platform puts connection at the center of care

Webinars

More Webinars

Analytics
Standby Eligibility and Claims Solutions: Diversify Your Risk & Ensure Business Continuity
Interoperability
Nursing Leadership, Operational Innovation, and Emerging Technologies with AONL
Artificial Intelligence
Loving the AI Revolution: How Automation is Humanizing Healthcare and Improving Provider Well-Being

Video

Ilir Kullolli, Stanford Medicine Children's Health_Las Vegas skyline Photo by halbergman/E+/Getty Images
HIMSS-ACCE working together to advance digital health
Vik Bajaj, Foresite Labs_Medical research Photo by Edward Jenner/pexels.com
Healthcare research is being affected by federal budget cuts
Priyanka Jain, Evvy_Hand holding sample vial Photo courtesy of Evvy
How one women's health startup tests fertility outcomes
Keisuke Nakagawa, UC San Diego Health_Las Vegas skyline Photo by halbergman/E+/Getty Images
Can technology help bring the human touch back to medicine?

More Stories

Lee Kim, HIMSS_Las Vegas skyline Photo by halbergman/E+/Getty Images
Past year's data breaches often stemmed from remediable cybersecurity gaps
Cathy Menkiena, Health Catalyst_Las Vegas skyline Photo by halbergman/E+/Getty Images
Innovative – and useful – tech is key to empowering care teams
Sameer Sethi of Hackensack Meridian Health on AI
Hackensack Meridian Chief AI Officer on the intersection of business and technology
Doctor checking and tracking information on a computer
HHS updates regulatory guides for the safe use of EHRs
Sameer Sethi, Hackensack Meridian Health_Computer neural network concept Photo by dan/Moment/Getty Images
Chief AI Officer on becoming one and working with the C-suite
Businessperson signing piece of paper
White House releases guidance on federal AI use and procurement
Dr. Ateev Mehrotra of Brown University School of Public Health on telehealth policy
Brown University policy expert talks about the future of telehealth flexibilities
Micky Tripathi, former HHS acting chief AI officer
Former National Coordinator headed to Mayo Clinic, reports say
Home

More News

  • MobiHealthNews
  • Healthcare Finance News
  • Healthcare Payers News

Newsletter Signup

HIMSS25 European Health Conference & Exhibition
HIMSS25 European Health Conference & Exhibition
Get ready for knowledge-sharing, all the latest innovations, and in-depth demos with Europe's most influential healthcare community.
10 - 12 June, 2025 | Paris
Learn More
AI in Healthcare Forum
AI in Healthcare Forum
The HIMSS AI in Healthcare Forum cuts through the hype to showcase real-world examples illustrating the transformative potential, and realistic challenges of AI application across the care continuum.
10 - 11 July 2025 | New York
Learn More

Footer Menu

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Reprints
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy

© 2025 Healthcare IT News is a publication of HIMSS Media

X

Topics

  • Video
  • Analytics
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Cloud Computing
  • EHR
  • Government & Policy
  • Interoperability
  • Patient Engagement
  • Population Health
  • Precision Medicine
  • Privacy & Security
  • Telehealth
  • Women In Health IT

Career

  • Events
  • Jobs
  • Research Papers
  • Webinars

More

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Special Projects
  • Video

Regions

  • ANZ
  • ASIA
  • EMEA
  • Global Edition

The Daily Brief Newsletter

Get daily news updates from Healthcare IT News.

Search form

Top Stories

Nurse checks tablet to communicate on shift
Zoom launches agentic AI-powered mobile comms for frontline staff
HIMSSCast logo
HIMSSCast: Should every healthcare organization have an AI strategy?
Vik Bajaj, Foresite Labs_Medical research Photo by Edward Jenner/pexels.com
Healthcare research is being affected by federal budget cuts